( Two second long uncomprehending stare. )

Hold up. Let me- let me see if I'm getting this right.

( Pause for emphasis, and a nice little level hand gesture to accompany it. )

This whole time... for months... I've been talking to you about... Angels. Demons. Heaven. Hell. The basic... multiversally accepted afterlife system.

( Big ol' sweeping gesture — the whole nine. )

We've practically been speaking two different languages? Is that what's happening right now? That's not a- a thing where you're from?